(sermon 1/15/23)
Matthew 4:12-23
Now when Jesus heard that John had been arrested, he withdrew to Galilee. He left Nazareth and made his home in Capernaum by the sea, in the territory of Zebulun and Naphtali, so that what had been spoken through the prophet Isaiah might be fulfilled: “Land of Zebulun, land of Naphtali, on the road by the sea, across the Jordan, Galilee of the Gentiles— the people who sat in darkness have seen a great light, and for those who sat in the region and shadow of death light has dawned.” From that time Jesus began to proclaim, “Repent, for the kingdom of heaven has come near.”
As he walked by the Sea of Galilee, he saw two brothers, Simon, who is called Peter, and Andrew his brother, casting a net into the sea—for they were fishermen. And he said to them, “Follow me, and I will make you fish for people.” Immediately they left their nets and followed him. As he went from there, he saw two other brothers, James son of Zebedee and his brother John, in the boat with their father Zebedee, mending their nets, and he called them. Immediately they left the boat and their father, and followed him. Jesus went throughout Galilee, teaching in their synagogues and proclaiming the good news of the kingdom and curing every disease and every sickness among the people.
=====
Last week, we heard John’s version of Jesus calling his first disciples. This week, we heard Matthew’s version of the same thing. While the end result is the same, there are some differences in the two versions. Last week, we heard that Andrew was a disciple of John the Baptist, who went off to follow Jesus after John identified Jesus as the messiah, and he went home to get his brother Peter to introduce him to Jesus. Today, in Matthew’s version, the two brothers are both fishermen working along the Sea of Galilee when Jesus walks by and calls them to follow him. In both versions, Jesus has some magnetic way about him to get these men to essentially drop everything and follow him, and that’s really the point of both of the stories. In today’s version, we heard that Jesus intrigued and appealed to the brothers by telling them to follow him, and saying that instead of trying to catch fish, he’d teach them to “fish for people.”
It was a good line for Jesus to make to them. Here he was, talking with a bunch of commercial fishermen working along the lakeshore; he spoke to them where they were, within their own context and experience. In short, it worked for his audience. But, with all due respect to Jesus, that analogy doesn’t really work when applying it to other people, in other contexts.
I’m not really criticizing Jesus; I guess I’m more knocking the way we, the church, locked onto those words and that analogy as a model for the mission of the church, and how we applied it over the years, actually causing real harm to literally millions of people in the process.
There are multiple problems with this analogy. First, when you’re fishing, no matter how crafty the fish are, there’s an inherent assumption – and reality – that the fisherman is smarter than the fish. It isn’t an equal match; the fisherman recognizes that they’re in a position of superiority in relation to the fish. Second, the whole basis of fishing is based on either deception or coercion – you’re either tempting the fish with some kind of attractive bait, wrapped around a hook; or, you’re surrounding them with a net against their will, and in either case forcing them out of their natural life and surroundings against their will. Third, the fisherman is doing it entirely for their own benefit, not for any benefit to the fish at all – and by definition, it’s not going to end well for the fish.
You see? This is hardly a good analogy for sharing God’s good news to people and welcoming them to take part in the unfolding of the reign of God. Despite that, this is exactly the way we’ve tried to spread the gospel. We’ve used deception, and coercion, and looked down on the intelligence of people and the validity of their own cultures as we more or less forced Christianity on them, sometimes with the threat of death if they didn’t accept the invitation, and ripping them out of their own native cultures and settings and replacing them with white European/American substitutes that were seen as superior; and we repeated it over and over again, and on every continent except Antarctica and that continent was spared simply because there aren’t any people there.
So as I thought about this, I wondered what a more helpful analogy of the mission of us, as Jesus’ disciples, and us together as the church, might be. An analogy that illustrated the idea that our mission isn’t to make disciples through deception or trickery or coercion, and one that respected where the person actually was in their own life. An analogy that drew people to God’s good news seen in Christ because they saw the remarkable love shown by Christ’s followers, and people wanting to be a part of that.
One analogy that popped into my mind that at least kept a water theme was being in a swimming pool, or a lake or some other favorite swimming hole, and having a great time, and warmly coaxing someone on the shore to “come on in, the water’s fine!” Or standing in the water, encouraging a child to have the courage to jump off the dock into the water and your waiting arms – or maybe, being the child on the dock who finally jumps in and experiences the joy of being in the water with everyone else.
Every analogy, like every parable, has its limitations and can become harmful if stretched too far. So as I said, I don’t, and wouldn’t, really fault Jesus for his fishing analogy; it was probably the perfect one in that moment, in that place, for those men. But I do think that for us, the better approach is “come on in, the water’s fine” – and living our lives in a way that actually shows that good news in a concrete, and appealing, way.
I think that’s important because of what I think the whole mission of the Church is. I suppose it could be put in many different ways, but I think one way we can summarize it is to say that the mission of the church is to “Raise, Train, and Equip People as Followers of Jesus; So They Can Then Love and Serve Others in the World, for the Sake of God’s Reign.” That’s important. And that summary has two distinct components. The first, and I’d suggest the most mission critical, is to raise, train, and equip ourselves as Jesus’ disciples, our own community of faith. It’s only after we do that that we can have any hope of effectively carrying out that second half of the church’s mission, that of loving and serving others in the world. Because if we don’t do the first, there simply won’t be anyone available to do the second. Really, this is what we see in Jesus’ own ministry, and in this text – first, he’s establishing and training his own group of disciples, then he focuses on applying his teaching and healings and other miracles out in the towns and villages.
Carrying out the church’s mission in this way isn’t a matter of selfish inward focus or misguided priorities. Psychologists and other healthcare professionals will tell us, correctly, that self-care is critical to our long-term health and well-being, and it’s crucial to us, the church, too, if we want to succeed at our mission. Before anything else we might do, we need to make sure that in our own setting, we’re raising, training, and equipping disciples – big and small, young and old. We need to be saying to them “come on in, the water’s fine!” and we need to be doing it in a way that they can see that we mean it, and beyond that, that it’s actually true.
Thanks be to God.